Eye color changing drops
In recent times, products claiming to change eye color through topical application have gained attention, especially on social media platforms. Brands like "Fancy Drops" and "IrisLuma" advertise eye drops that purportedly alter the iris's pigmentation, offering users a new eye color without surgical intervention.
Claims and Products
These products often assert that their formulations can adjust the natural levels of melanin in the iris, leading to a gradual change in eye color. For instance, some manufacturers suggest that consistent use over several weeks can lighten dark brown eyes to a lighter shade or even blue. Such products are available on various online platforms, including Amazon, where they are marketed with names like "IrisLuma Advanced Eye Color Changing Drops" and "Spectraeye Color Changing Drops."
Safety and Efficacy Concerns
Despite their availability, these eye color-changing drops are not approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO) has expressed concerns regarding these products, stating that there is no scientific evidence supporting their effectiveness. Moreover, if these drops were capable of altering melanin levels in the iris, they could potentially cause harm, including light sensitivity, eye inflammation, and even vision loss.
Although these eye color-changing drops are widely available online and marketed as a non-invasive alternative to cosmetic surgery or contact lenses, they have not received approval from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). This lack of regulation raises concerns among medical professionals, particularly ophthalmologists and optometrists, who emphasize that no scientific evidence supports the effectiveness of these drops. Despite bold claims by manufacturers that their products gradually alter eye color by reducing melanin in the iris, there is no peer-reviewed research validating such effects.
The American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO) has openly warned consumers against using these products, explaining that melanin levels in the iris are biologically stable and do not change without external intervention, such as laser treatments or surgical procedures. If a substance were capable of reducing melanin, it could disrupt the eye’s natural pigmentation, potentially leading to significant side effects. The iris plays a crucial role in regulating how much light enters the eye, and any artificial alteration in pigmentation could result in light sensitivity, visual disturbances, and an increased risk of conditions like photophobia (heightened sensitivity to light).
In more severe cases, tampering with iris pigmentation could cause inflammation, irritation, or even structural damage, leading to complications such as uveitis (inflammation of the eye's middle layer) or increased intraocular pressure, which could elevate the risk of glaucoma. Some ophthalmologists caution that if these drops contain unlisted or untested chemicals, they could trigger allergic reactions, corneal damage, or long-term vision impairment.
Furthermore, because these products are not subject to FDA oversight, their ingredients, concentration levels, and potential side effects remain unknown. Without clinical trials or transparent research, users are essentially experimenting with their vision health, unaware of the possible long-term consequences. Many professionals urge individuals seeking a change in eye color to consider safer alternatives, such as prescription-colored contact lenses, which are approved by regulatory agencies and fitted by eye care professionals to reduce health risks.
While the appeal of a quick, non-surgical method to change eye color is understandable, experts strongly advise against using these drops until more scientific studies confirm their safety and effectiveness. Until then, any product claiming to permanently alter eye color should be approached with caution, as the risks far outweigh any unverified benefits.
The American Optometric Association (AOA) also advises against the use of such products, emphasizing that no FDA-tested or approved color-changing eye drops are currently on the market.
Expert Opinions
Dr. Alina Djougarian, an ophthalmologist with Northwell Health in New York, has highlighted that claims suggesting a "brown eye turning blue" through these drops amount to false advertising. She emphasizes that there is nothing approved by the FDA that can achieve such a transformation.
Dr. Alina Djougarian, an ophthalmologist with Northwell Health in New York, has expressed serious concerns over the marketing of eye color-changing drops, stating that claims suggesting a brown eye can turn blue through the use of topical solutions are nothing more than false advertising. She emphasizes that there is no FDA-approved product capable of altering iris pigmentation in this way, and any brand suggesting otherwise is misleading consumers with unproven claims.
Eye color is primarily determined by the concentration and distribution of melanin in the iris, which is genetically set and does not fluctuate naturally over time. While certain medical conditions, such as ocular albinism or Horner’s syndrome, can cause shifts in iris color, these are pathological changes rather than cosmetic transformations. The idea that a topical solution can safely and permanently break down melanin in a controlled way has no scientific backing, and any attempt to chemically alter iris pigmentation carries significant risks.
Even in the field of medical research, the only known methods for changing eye color involve laser procedures that selectively target melanin in the iris, breaking it down gradually over time. These laser treatments, which are still under study and not widely approved, carry risks such as increased light sensitivity, ocular pressure changes, and long-term vision complications. If a simple eye drop were truly capable of achieving a similar effect, it would require regulatory approval and extensive clinical trials to assess safety. No such trials exist, which raises red flags about the legitimacy of these products.
Dr. Djougarian warns that products claiming to modify eye color are not only ineffective but potentially hazardous, as many are formulated with undisclosed ingredients that could cause eye irritation, allergic reactions, or even long-term damage. Without proper regulation, there is no way to verify whether these solutions contain substances that could disrupt the natural balance of the eye, leading to dryness, inflammation, or corneal issues.
Furthermore, she stresses that consumers should be cautious of misleading marketing tactics, particularly those that claim dramatic transformations without offering any medical research or FDA clearance. The lack of transparency surrounding these products suggests that many may be relying on placebo effects or temporary visual changes rather than actual pigmentation shifts. Some eye drops may cause temporary brightening or reddening of the sclera (the white part of the eye), which could create the illusion of a lighter iris color, but this effect is superficial and short-lived.
The safest and most effective way to alter eye color remains the use of prescription colored contact lenses, which are specifically designed for cosmetic changes and are regulated by health authorities to ensure they meet safety standards. Unlike unapproved drops, colored lenses undergo extensive testing to ensure that they do not harm the eye or increase the risk of infections. Any legitimate medical advancement in the field of eye color alteration would require rigorous scientific validation, something these drops currently lack.
Dr. Djougarian's stance reflects the broader consensus among ophthalmologists, who caution against using unverified eye products for cosmetic purposes. Until real, regulated medical advancements in eye pigmentation modification become available, consumers are strongly advised to steer clear of any product claiming to permanently change eye color with drops alone.
Alternative Methods
For individuals who want to change their eye color, the safest and most effective option remains colored contact lenses, which offer an instant and customizable transformation without the risks associated with unapproved chemical solutions. Unlike eye color-changing drops, which lack scientific backing and FDA approval, colored lenses are medically regulated and designed specifically for cosmetic and vision correction purposes.
These lenses come in a variety of shades, ranging from subtle color enhancements that intensify natural eye color to opaque lenses that completely alter the appearance of the iris, even for those with dark brown eyes. Whether someone is looking for a natural shift in hue or a more dramatic effect, there are multiple options available through licensed eye care professionals.
One of the most important aspects of using colored contacts safely is obtaining a valid prescription from an optometrist or ophthalmologist. Even if the lenses are non-corrective and purely cosmetic, they still need to be properly fitted to the individual’s eyes. Every person’s corneal shape and eye structure are unique, and ill-fitting lenses can cause discomfort, blurred vision, or even abrasions to the surface of the eye.
Improper use of contact lenses, including those purchased from unregulated online sources, carries significant risks. Some of the most common complications associated with cheap, non-prescription lenses include:
- Corneal infections (keratitis): Wearing non-medical-grade lenses, particularly those made from lower-quality materials, can trap bacteria against the eye, leading to painful infections that can cause permanent vision loss if left untreated.
- Oxygen deprivation: The cornea requires oxygen to stay healthy, and poorly manufactured lenses can block airflow, leading to corneal swelling, irritation, and damage over time.
- Scratches or ulcers on the cornea: If lenses are not properly fitted, they can rub against the eye, creating small abrasions that can become infected and lead to serious long-term damage.
- Allergic reactions: Some materials used in non-FDA-approved colored contacts may cause itching, redness, and eye discomfort, making them unsuitable for prolonged wear.
Another major concern is counterfeit and unregulated colored contacts, which are often sold online without a prescription requirement. These knockoff lenses may not meet safety standards and can contain harmful dyes or materials that leach into the eye, causing irritation or toxicity. Studies have found that some illegally sold cosmetic lenses are contaminated with bacteria before they even reach the consumer, posing an extreme risk of infection.
To avoid these dangers, eye care professionals recommend purchasing lenses from trusted optical retailers, ophthalmologist offices, or reputable online vendors that require a prescription. Proper lens hygiene is also essential—wearers should never share lenses, always clean them with sterile solution, and follow the recommended wearing schedule to prevent complications.
For those who desire a permanent eye color change, medical procedures like laser iris depigmentation and iris implant surgery do exist, but both come with significant risks, including glaucoma, chronic eye inflammation, and irreversible vision problems. Because of these dangers, most ophthalmologists do not recommend surgical eye color changes, reinforcing that colored contact lenses remain the safest, most effective, and most widely available option.
While the idea of changing eye color is appealing to many, taking shortcuts with unregulated products can have serious consequences. Colored contact lenses, when obtained through the proper channels, provide a safe, reversible, and customizable way to achieve the desired look while protecting long-term eye health.
Sources:
What Ophthalmologists Want You to Know About Eye Color-Changing Drops - AAO
Drops That Change Eye Color? Experts Sound the Alarm - MedPage Today
Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976: Allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education, and research.
Comments
Post a Comment